Rev. John J. McEvoy
1896-1900

Rev. Daniel J. Fant
1938-1943

Msgr. Clement P. J. Krug
January - May 1973

Rev. William T. Connolly
1904-1916

Rev. John F. Warren
1943-1944

Msgr. James J. Lynch
1973-1985

Rev. Michael A. Walsh
1916-1920

Rev. Ernest A. Badecker
1944-1947

Msgr. Dermot R. Brennan
1985-2005

Rev. Francis A. Kinery
1920-1924

Msgr. John J. Bingham
1947-1950

Rev. Joseph F. Bisignano
2005-Present

Rev. William C. Ryder
1924-1927

Msgr. Robert E. Delaney
1950-1963

Msgr. Patrick A. O'Leary
1927-1938

Msgr. Daniel H. Daly
1963-1973